Barclay Goodrow made his highly anticipated return to Madison Square Garden on Thursday night after everything that went down between him and the New York Rangers. The night was capped off with a 3-1 victory for the Rangers over the San Jose Sharks,

Barclay Goodrow was the cap casualty for the Rangers this past summer, when the organization had to ruthlessly put the veteran forward on waivers to circumvent his 15-team no-trade list and complete a pre-arranged deal with the Sharks.

With Barclay Goodrow making his return to MSG this week, we will look at why his tenure with the Rangers was always doomed to fail.